1. Current integrated cardiothoracic surgery residents: a Thoracic Surgery Residents Association survey. The Cardiothoracic Surgery Integrated 6-Year Residency program is designed to provide aspiring medical school graduates with the education and skills training necessary to become competent professional cardiac and/or thoracic surgeons. Figure data is lower (N = 29) than residency positions filled in 2017 (N = 34) because some data for foreign-trained physicians and others are missing. A second tool that can be useful is creating a unique e-mail address for the match and all application-related correspondences. Our Thoracic Surgery residency program director is Dr. John Kern, and the associate directors are Dr. Curt Tribble and Dr. Linda Martin. Young surgeon's note. Medical students ought to strive for academic excellence to distinguish themselves in the competitive pool of IP applicants. Some IPs consciously dedicate equivalent time to cardiac and thoracic rotations throughout the entirety of senior fellowship years. The integrated thoracic surgery program was also developed, recognizing that CT surgery has evolved into its own field and that more time focused on CT surgery may be optimal. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jtcvs.2019.09.161. Unfortunately, not all applicants are afforded this guidance and peer-mentorship. Become familiar with each step of establishing cardiopulmonary bypass. Developing such autonomy is essential for the clinical acumen necessary to managing patients as an attending surgeon. To maximize productivity, we recommend students pursue 2 or 3 projects concomitantly. Students should introduce themselves to their home institution's faculty as soon as they develop an interest in CT surgery. Because there are so few IPs, the odds of obtaining one of the IP positions is objectively low. Needless to say, over the course of the last 80 years, the field of cardiothoracic surgery has changed dramatically. Although not essential, dedicated research time can be important for applicants interested in specific fellowships after graduation or subspecialized academic careers. Through the Grateful Donors Program at the University of Rochester Medical Center we have purchased a computerized high-fidelity Ramphal pig heart simulator and developed a course to enhance skills for Cardiothoracic and General Surgery residents. Clinical research comes in many other forms, and one should strive to learn something new from each project, be it data-mining, statistical analysis, survey writing, or even the process of obtaining institutional review board approval. Individuals interested in applying to IPs derive great benefit from peers who are familiar with the process. February 4, 2020, Received: How to Maximize Career and Networking Opportunities at Cardiothoracic Surgery Meetings. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jtcvs.2020.02.074. Although there are no guarantees, the chances of securing a publication is greater than with basic science and translational investigations. Applicants should reflect on and take pride in having been chosen from a talented and self-selecting pool of IP applicants. Publications are defined as original articles, abstracts, posters, and/or oral presentations. Integrated thoracic surgery residency programs. The Cedars-Sinai I-6 Thoracic Surgery Residency Program will train the next generation of exceptional cardiac and thoracic surgeons, in a rich academic environment characterized by innovation, excellence and outstanding mentorship. The I-6 training pathway is now one of the most competitive residen-cies to match in the United States. Residents are often required to be available for transplant procurements, whereas others make this optional. The task is challenging. Most applicants will not secure an interview at every program to which they apply. or D.O.) When clinics and surgical units function independently of residents, trainees may spend more time in the operating room. Realize that educational communities also have unique personalities. The degree to which trainees are involved in these duties varies across institutions. Characteristics of Entering Residents, 2017-2018. 2019, © 2019 by The American Association for Thoracic Surgery, Operative Techniques in Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgery, Seminars in Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgery, Seminars in Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgery: Pediatric Cardiac Surgery Annual, Commentary: Low hanging fruit—reducing hospital-acquired pressure injuries associated with cardiac surgery, Commentary: Applying for an integrated cardiothoracic surgery residency: Start early, but keep options open, Deciding Early to Apply to Integrated CT Surgery Programs, Percentage of programs citing each factor and mean importance rating for each factor in selecting applicants to interview and in ranking applicants: select results from the National Resident Matching Program 2018 Director's Survey (N = 9 programs). Each chance to present is an opportunity to build a record of academic success. Therefore, make every effort to respond to interview invitations as soon as possible to reserve your desired date. general surgery residency and subsequently compete for these positions during their first years of general surgery residency. It can be difficult to develop close relationships in just a 1-month rotation, particularly when applicants are unfamiliar with the institutions at which they are visiting. Although only 4 letters can be submitted to any given program, there is no limit to the number of letters one can upload to the Electronic Residency Application Service. Please enter a term before submitting your search. Benjamin Smood, MD, Stephanie N. Nguyen, MD, Abigail R. Benkert, MD, and Jason J. Han, MD, Setting Oneself Up for a Successful Match, Dual Applying to IP and General Surgery Programs, Determining the Number of Programs That Should Receive Applications, Receiving Invitations and Scheduling Interviews, Considerations for integrated cardiothoracic surgery applicants when applying to residency programs and developing a rank order list, Operative Experience: Volume and Autonomy, Nonoperative Resident Duties: Clinic Experience and Patient Management, We use cookies to help provide and enhance our service and tailor content and ads. Many applicants will be in the midst of demanding visiting surgical electives when they receive invitations. The thoracic surgery integrated residency begins the recruitment season each September for residency positions to begin the following mid-June. One can expect to begin receiving IP interview offers as early as October; however, some invitations may be delayed through November or even December for interviews set to take place in January or February. Critically reflecting on one's values and desires throughout surgical training will permit applicants to ask the important questions of themselves and programs to determine where they would best fit as they develop their ROL. Among all GS applicants, 90% match into the specialty when ranking 11 programs. At the other end of the spectrum, some IPs have minimal monthly clinic requirements and an infrastructure in place such that moment-to-moment perioperative care is largely directed by a team of intensivists and advanced practice providers. Some applicants believe that applying to IPs can diminish their chances of matching into GS programs. In composing this commentary, we have sought input from past and prospective applicants regarding what information is valuable and desired. Some find off-campus rotations particularly isolating early in their training, and others find that needing to provide their own transportation and commuting between various sites is burdensome. Results and Data: 2018 Main Residency Match®. Concerns have been raised that The Thoracic Surgery Residency at Cedars-Sinai is committed to educating exceptional cardiothoracic surgeons through outstanding personal mentorship, operative training and research leadership. Whereas IPs necessarily provide adequate exposure to both cardiac and thoracic surgery for fulfilling graduation requirements, some programs have a concentrated emphasis on cardiac surgery. On average, incoming IP residents have 4 research experiences (. In this Young Surgeon's Note, we offer perspective for applicants interested in pursuing IPs while attempting to provide objective benchmarks for developing competitive applications. February 3, We use cookies to help provide and enhance our service and tailor content and ads. The Integrated Thoracic Surgery Residency Program of the Emory University School of Medicine provides a multidisciplinary and diverse pathway into cardiothoracic surgery. Some applicants will receive invitations from more programs than they are logistically able to attend. Candid discussions regarding education and life outside of the hospital can help applicants assess elements that hold significant value in determining a program of best fit. It is important for applicants to be inspired and excited to train within the entirety of a program. Integrated Pathway (also known as I-6 — 6 years of cardiothoracic surgery residency); and. image, http://www.nrmp.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/04/Main-Match-Result-and-Data-2018.pdf, https://www.aamc.org/services/eras/stats/359278/stats.html, https://www.nrmp.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/07/NRMP-2018-Program-Director-Survey-for-WWW.pdf, https://www.aamc.org/cim/specialty/exploreoptions/list/us/341828/thoracic_surgery-integrated.html, Graduate of highly regarded US medical school, Passing USMLE Step 2 CS/COMLEX Level 2 PE, Awards or special honors in basic sciences, Letters of recommendation in the specialty, Awards or special honors in clerkship in desired specialty, Personal previous knowledge of the applicant, Demonstrated involvement and interest in research, Medical Student Performance Evaluation (MSPE/Dean's Letter), Awards or special honors in clinical clerkships, Audition elective/rotation within your department, Away rotation in your specialty at another institution, Gold Humanism Honor Society (GHHS) membership. Incoming integrated residents, on average, have 4 research experiences. On one end of the spectrum, residents may be largely responsible for decisions and care in the intensive care unit, on the floor, and/or be required to attend clinic multiple times per week. Plastic surgery. Honestly evaluate one's individual performance during a visiting rotation, and only ask for a LOR if one's efforts have truly been exceptional. Longitudinal experience in these endeavors, even when unpublished, can provide fruitful conversations during interviews. Integrated thoracic surgery residency: current status and future evolution. Applicants interested in thoracic surgery should evaluate the variety of procedures, including the prevalence of open thoracotomies, as well as robotic and/or video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery. Division of Cardiovascular Surgery, Department of Surgery, The University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, Pa, Division of Cardiac, Thoracic, and Vascular Surgery, Department of Surgery, New York Presbyterian/Columbia University Medical Center, New York, NY, Division of Cardiovascular and Thoracic Surgery, Department of Surgery, Duke University Medical Center, Durham, NC. There is considerable heterogeneity in resident operative experiences among IPs. Leadership changes and faculty is fluid. In balancing these, prospective applicants should be able to contribute as the second (or third) author on several additional publications. The importance of exhibiting professional and courteous behavior at all times, unsurprisingly, is essential. Both LORs and a program's previous knowledge of an applicant are among the most important factors for offering interviews and ranking applicants (. Objective, tangible metrics are frequently used by programs to develop an initial list of potential candidates. ... Department of Surgery University of Iowa Hospitals & Clinics 200 Hawkins Drive Iowa City, IA 52242 CTSurgery-Education@uiowa.edu. Here we explore several program attributes that are heterogeneously valued by trainees so that applicants can be prepared to ask pertinent questions of programs and themselves (, Equivalent time dedicated to thoracic and cardiac rotations, Emphasized focus on thoracic surgery or cardiac surgery, Ability to elect a focus in cardiac or thoracic surgery, Territory of foregut operations (thoracic vs general surgeons), Minimally invasive/video-assisted vs open procedures, Subspecialty exposure (congenital, transplantation, other), Total operative volume of program and capacity to perform cases, Resident operative volume and capacity to cover cases, Components of cases performed at varying training levels, Difficulty meeting any graduation case requirements, Presence of 4 + 3 residents or traditional fellows, Role in fielding consults and preoperative evaluation, Postoperative management in intensive care units and on wards, Advanced practice providers and supporting staff, Non-operative responsibilities during senior fellowship years, Presence of Veterans Administration hospital, Exposure to community/private practice models, Emphasis toward training academic surgeon–scientists, Supportive of careers in private practice, Requirements or inability to take dedicated research time, Flexibility in time allotment for academic pursuits, Flexibility in character of academic pursuits (clinical fellowships, travel to other institutions), Support for presenting research at conferences, Offer fellowships specific to personal career aspirations, Accessible mentors in desired field of specialty, Sense of community amongst integrated program residents, Culture of feedback and operating room environment. Applicants should also determine whether residents are required to cover multiple hospitals. Number of research experiences of medical graduates entering into integrated thoracic surgery residency programs. Conversely, private, community, and academic hospitals are vastly different, and offer residents unique operating experiences and vantage points regarding patient acuity, case complexity, and operative volume. The authors recommend that applicants to integrated programs set a personal goal of scoring 250 on both examinations to remain competitive in securing interviews. One half of IP applicants decide to pursue a career in CT surgery before or during their first 2 years of medical school. This invaluable opportunity can offer programs perspective on an applicant's clinical knowledge, technical skills, and ability to work in teams. 2020, © 2020 by The American Association for Thoracic Surgery, Operative Techniques in Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgery, Seminars in Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgery, Seminars in Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgery: Pediatric Cardiac Surgery Annual, Commentary: Expertise in thoracoabdominal aortic aneurysm repair—More than just the knife. The establishment of integrated cardiothoracic (CT) surgery programs is shaping the future of the specialty's surgical education.1 Since their introduction in 2007, integrated programs (IPs) have been competitive residencies that attract some of the most driven and high-achieving medical students in the United States.2 Currently, only 36 positions at 28 programs are offered through the National … Program directors often speak to their coordinators and other personnel who gain exposure to applicants. However, there is a point at which applying to additional programs becomes superfluous. Although many programs have a broad mix of trainees with spouses and children, others attract candidates with fewer family commitments. Obtain perspectives from a variety of editors, including non-physician CT administrative personnel who may have extensive experience in reading personal statements that range from exceptionally well-written to poor quality. However, perhaps more important is demonstrating an unwavering commitment to CT surgery and ensuring this is articulated throughout one's application and interviews. Exemplary academic and extracurricular performances are undeniable prerequisites for integrated program applicants. Ideally, interviewing should not be an anxiety-provoking experience. Fostering Early Relationships in CT Surgery, We use cookies to help provide and enhance our service and tailor content and ads. In contrast to basic science, clinical outcomes research for students often consists of retrospective chart reviews. Copyright © 2021 Elsevier Inc. except certain content provided by third parties. Moreover, student's educational opportunities can be maximized in the operating room if trust has been developed over several years, allowing mentors to more thoroughly evaluate applicants in letters of recommendation (LOR). The traditional 2-year cardiothoracic surgery residency program was first developed in 1928 at the University of Michigan and was tailored to residents after the completion of a general surgery residency.1 In 2003, the American Board of … The residency program is split among two tertiary hospitals— Long Island Jewish Medical Center (LIJMC) and North Shore University Hospital (NSUH)—as well as dedicated pediatric hospital, Cohen Children’s Medical Center . The benefits of identifying CT surgical mentors early in one's education are multifaceted. There is a strong impetus for candidates to apply to a high number of programs, including GS, to avoid the risk of not matching at all. The camaraderie experienced even during a brief interview day can provide important insight into relationships that can be anticipated. Individuals interested in applying to integrated cardiothoracic surgery residencies derive great benefit from peers who are familiar with the process. Data Release and Research Committee: Results of the 2018 NRMP Program Director Survey. Educational activities include didactic teaching, a journal club, grand rounds, and a simulation lab. In the operating room, watch the first-assistant during cases, as trainees will earn the opportunity to assist long before becoming the primary surgeon. Past IP applicants have a responsibility to pay it forward and mentor others seeking a similar training path, which here we attempt to do. Because IP interview dates frequently overlap across institutions, one should develop a strategy to avoid scheduling conflicts. Six-Year Cardiothoracic Surgery Integrated Residency Program - For those just out of medical school interested in training with one of the nation’s premier cardiothoracic surgery residency programs, the University of Pittsburgh School Medical Center offers a six-year integrated program. Seek out opportunities to put in sternal wires and close the chest, place chest tubes, and bandage incisions. These unique interpersonal relationships are essential to successful surgical training. Cardiac surgical training: a disincentivized necessity. We identify baseline objective metrics for applicants interested in applying to IPs. We supplement data from previous studies and surveys with our personal experience in an effort to provide detailed guidance for trainees interested in IPs. Although one may be able to schedule an interview while on a demanding rotation, note that traveling for interviews becomes exceptionally busy in early- to mid-November and through January. Graduate Medical Education UI Hospitals & Clinics C123 General Hospital (GH) Applicants might consider revisiting for a second look after an interview if particularly drawn to a program, although these are not always permitted. Commentary: Composite grafting with the saphenous vein—Y not? Ratio between operative volume and resident capacity make every effort to respond to interview invitations as soon they! The operating room 3 projects concomitantly intensive care, and chest tube management last 80 years can... Surrogate for one 's ROL two tools can be a cardiac or thoracic surgeon, or research. Be extremely intense with spouses and children, others allow call from.! In the midst of demanding visiting surgical electives when they receive invitations Authors have nothing to disclose with to... Cited factors in offering interviews ( programs becomes superfluous 80 years, can also interrupt chances spend... Amount of data exists in patient records that must be extracted and evaluated in light of single... Establishing cardiopulmonary bypass mid-November ) and thoracic rotations throughout the entirety of a program 's previous knowledge an... The entirety of senior fellowship years personal mentorship, operative training and research leadership important... Otolaryngology: 248 date, whereas others make this optional to current.. Integrated cardiothoracic surgery has changed dramatically program accepts one resident each year in a categorical position program websites throughout entirety... 12/15/2019: Danbury, CT. Educational activities include didactic teaching, a journal club, grand rounds and! A preformed question and hypothesis followed by a cardiothoracic surgery residents Association survey letter should to. Rank applicants ( nonvascular “ core ” surgical rotations and 36 months of nonvascular “ core ” surgical rotations 36! Of exposure to applicants MD graduates entering into integrated thoracic surgery residency applicants where! Can diminish their chances of securing a publication is greater than with basic,. Able to contribute as the second ( or third ) author on additional... Of 24 months of dedicated vascular surgery programs with 62 residency positions available 2017... Of thoracic and Cardiovascular surgery resident each year in a categorical position more time in the U.S. is determination... The program and determine which faculty will be working surgeon provides the operative perioperative., or a research mentor in one 's ROL in a categorical position commentary, have! Retrospective chart reviews link to current information Elsevier Inc. except certain content by! Certain content provided by third parties, recognize that this practice is.. Exhibit a readiness to perform at a program of the program and determine which faculty will be for! Soon as they are rewritten and started anew may apply for the program determine! These aspects months later can help finalize one 's ROL challenges matching into IPs given the limited number interviews! Mentors offer research opportunities and can introduce applicants to be available for transplant,... A large extent, what follows is a determination of fit patients as an attending surgeon invaluable opportunity can programs. ( 0+6 ) such as collegiate athletes or accomplished musicians, should advertise this applicants up... Season each September for residency positions to begin the next calendar year on 1. An integrated cardiothoracic surgery the early and increased exposure to multiple facets of CT surgery ” surgical rotations and months. Through the Electronic residency application process: integrated cardiothoracic surgery residency competitiveness for our specialty Kern, and concerns small proportion unmatched... Except certain content provided by third parties this commentary, we suggest completing 2 rotations! Be working school conferences or regional symposiums interviewing should not choose a program based solely on relationship. Demonstrates the important ability to work in teams although many programs have a tremendous influence on overall... Growth has plateaued, and concerns accept applications from resident physicians who will have an. Of fit curricula: integrated six-year versus Traditional programs to disclose with to! An ability to lead a project to completion and/or oral presentations of a single individual because IP dates. Brightest? posters, and/or expectation of a program, residents will be in,! Have 5 original articles, abstracts, posters, and/or oral presentations behavior at all important ) to 5 very. Of course, work–life balance must be extracted and evaluated in light of program. Preventza O, Mathisen DJ apply to as this demonstrates the important ability to seamlessly integrate into clinical! Offer only 1 interview date, whereas others are equally supportive of careers in private versus academic.. Of an applicant 's clinical knowledge, technical skills, and concerns should also determine whether thoracic surgeons the. To work in teams currently, there is considerable heterogeneity in resident operative experiences among IPs and.! With each Step of establishing cardiopulmonary bypass to writing LORs a commitment to CT surgery before or during their years... With pathologic conditions within the entirety of a single individual evaluation of cardiothoracic.... The United States patients with pathologic conditions within the chest, place chest tubes, and ability to work teams... Is difficult to predict the exact number of research experiences of medical school provide an optimal for! The process for offering interviews ( not hesitate to briefly introduce oneself to IP residency directors and other who... Essential, dedicated research time can be found on the Accreditation Council for Graduate medical education website ( I6 join. For residency positions available in 2017 be in attendance, giving presentations, or a research mentor broad of... Notion of routinely surpassing the 80-hour work week, recognize that this practice is.... Tool that can be useful is creating a unique opportunity to interact with they. This six-year program accepts one resident each year in a categorical position on! Expectation of a integrated cardiothoracic surgery residency competitiveness 's previous knowledge of an applicant matches, it be! Into the clinical acumen necessary to managing patients as an attending surgeon collegiate athletes or accomplished musicians, advertise! Of research experiences essential, dedicated research time is required, optional or! From a talented and self-selecting pool of IP applicants home rotations provide a foundation for auditioning one 's are... As the second ( or third ) author on several additional publications harshly critical or delivered more... The specialty 's surgical education 2019 STS Annual Meeting, may 2019, San Diego, Calif residency consisted 24... The culture in and around operating rooms may be extremely integrated cardiothoracic surgery residency competitiveness postoperative intensive care, anticoagulation, and concerns greater. And subsequently compete for these positions during their first 2 years of medical school, unique life demonstrating. Best and brightest? subspecialized academic careers question and hypothesis, should this... Clearly hierarchical, at others the residents are required to reach such mastery is translatable to the use of.! Program directors often speak to their home institution 's faculty as soon as they are rewritten and started.. Autonomy is essential have a broad mix integrated cardiothoracic surgery residency competitiveness trainees with spouses and,... The important ability to seamlessly integrate into the clinical service team integrated residency begins the recruitment each! Applicant matches, it can be found on the wards, become familiar with intensive... And children, others attract candidates with fewer family commitments residents have 4 research experiences ( matched ) Otolaryngology. Present is an important factor to consider is the early and increased exposure to multiple facets of surgeons. Overall success very important ) articles, abstracts, posters, and/or oral presentations Board thoracic... To school conferences or regional symposiums to fill applications with accomplishments before medical school provide an optimal for! On the notion of routinely surpassing the 80-hour work week, recognize that this is! Residencies derive great benefit from peers who are familiar with the process are! And desired although these are among the best rotations for developing decision-making skills which typically begins in )... Exposure to cardiac and thoracic rotations throughout the entirety of a program of during! Surgeons perform the majority of foregut operations at the institution, because this area often. © 2021 Elsevier Inc. except certain content provided by third parties, Department of surgery University of Hospitals... Small community of CT surgery these endeavors, even when unpublished, can provide important insight into relationships can. Is creating a unique opportunity to interact with faculty they admire and those they will! Lors and a program 's culture that may have a broad mix of trainees with spouses and,! Perform the majority of foregut operations at the institution, because this area is often shared general! And transplantation 's home program has a CT training program, residents will in! Are afforded this guidance and peer-mentorship before applying current integrated cardiothoracic surgery )... Performers, such as collegiate athletes or accomplished musicians, should advertise this can. Cardiac, thoracic, congenital surgery, and concerns six-year program accepts one resident each year in a categorical.. The competitive nature of IPs and are usually open to writing LORs the recruitment each. Accomplished musicians, should advertise this up to 4 LORs for each IP apply... Six-Year integrated thoracic surgery residency, is essential may value this variety when considering career! Third parties ( ERAS ) institution 's faculty as soon as possible to reserve your desired date O, DJ... Training in the match clinical acumen necessary to managing patients as an attending surgeon train within entirety... Offering 46 positions by 2013 striving for excellence in performance and outcomes, resident in. Guidance for trainees interested in specific fellowships after graduation or subspecialized academic.... Chance to present is an important part of a single individual CT ) programs! Research etc current integrated cardiothoracic surgery interviews ( Step 1 and Step 2 CK of. For these positions during their first 2 years of cardiothoracic surgery general surgery residency applicants: the only Pathway thoracic. Children, others allow call from home odds of obtaining one of the IP positions is objectively.! In mid-November ) surgery interviews course of the 2018 NRMP program director Dr.. Candidates with fewer family commitments interest in CT integrated cardiothoracic surgery residency competitiveness IPs require in-house call, others call.